• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Little Italy: Authentic Pizza & Italian Flavors in Clay, NY

Little Italy, located in Clay, NY, is a cozy pizza restaurant known for its authentic and creative Italian dishes. Customers rave about their exceptional pizzas, including unique flavors like Bang Bang Chicken and classic Eggplant Parmigiana, which is praised for its perfect balance of cheese and sauce. Beyond pizza, the menu features standout items such as Chicken Riggies, Fettuccini Alfredo, and flavorful house-made sauces that elevate every bite. The friendly staff and inviting atmosphere make it an ideal spot for casual dining or takeout. Little Italy beautifully blends traditional flavors with contemporary touches, delivering a satisfying and memorable Italian experience.

Little Italy at a glance

  • Address 4599 NY-31 suite 1, Clay, NY 13041, United States
  • Phone +1 315-622-5000
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Little Italy: Reviews & Ratings

Colin Martin
5

Decent Pizza. Good dough. We ordered Small Eggplant Parmesan Pizza Pepperoni Calzone Buffalo Bites Garlic Sticks Was happy with the quality and portion of all the food. We ordered pickup over the phone. Will be back. Friendly service.

Adam Walcott
5

I got take out. I usually get my pizza elsewhere but decided to try this spot cuz they have a hot dog garbage plate. Its pretty amazing, I'll definitely be back for that. And also, discovered that the pizza was excellent too! So bonus. I'd recommend this place to anyone. The restaurant seating area is a little small, definitely a good hangout for a couple of friends or possibly a casual date.

Gracia Roulan
5

Literally the most delicious pizza we've had! The bang bang chicken slice was surprisingly scrumptious! Fettuccini Alfredo was awesome and even the house dressing for the salad was yummy. Would highly recommend and we will definitely be back! And we're telling all our friends.

David Bragdon
5

They offer the best eggplant parmigiana I have every had anywhere. Light and flavorful, with just the right proportions of cheese and sauce. Additionally, for the pasta side, the house-made light red smoky kind of sauce is delicious. And, of course, the pizza is very good, with many varieties. This is a very modern, contemporary restaurant with genuine traditional good taste.

Zachary Lansing
5

Have gone there a few times now. Their chicken riggies are great and I'm picky when it comes to riggies. Their pizzas are very creative and taste great. The staff also talked to me while waiting for my food. Good stuff, great spot to pick up food after work or for a game.

Brandon Scott
5

4 words...Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza ! Got it? Good! Now pick up the phone and wait for your tastebuds to perform the most titillating dance of joy with the disappearance of every perfectly baked slice. We are frequent flyers to the establishment and also appreciate the ability to chit chat with the friendly staff. We order this gem every time we have surprise guests or friends! Our dogs also always enjoy the Crust :)

Donnita M
5

They always make me feel welcomed. The food is delicious. Try the stuffed shells you won't be disappointed. Also, love the hot honey pepperoni pizza. Love it here.

Lynne Elardo
5

I stopped in here today on my way to my next appointment and I grabbed a slice of Sicilian pizza and I also got a whole sausage and pepperoni pie. This pizza is fantastic!! The only thing I’m disappointed about is that I did not take a picture but I can tell you it is definitely worth stopping at. There are probably 20 to 25 different pizzas if not more in the case that you can choose from first slices this is by far the best pizza place that I’ve been into in a very long time. Loved it so much my daughter and I are going back to get stuff tonight for dinner! Awesome job and Welcome to the Neighbourhood

Location

  • Little Italy
    Little Italy
    4599 NY-31 suite 1, Clay, NY 13041, United States Hotline: +1 315-622-5000

Little Italy, located in Clay, NY, is a standout pizza restaurant that delivers a true taste of Italian tradition with a modern twist. From the moment you step in or place a pickup order, you’re met with friendly service and a menu that goes beyond the typical slice.

The pizza here is a highlight, boasting a well-crafted dough that strikes the perfect balance between light and satisfying. Whether it’s the classic eggplant parmesan pizza or more creative offerings like the bang bang chicken slice, each pie reveals layers of fresh, bold flavors that linger pleasantly. The quality and portion sizes consistently impress, making it a solid choice for both quick meals and leisurely hangouts.

But what really sets Little Italy apart are the diverse and thoughtfully prepared dishes beyond pizza. The eggplant parmigiana has been praised as the best around—delicately layered with cheese and sauce that don’t overpower, paired with a subtly smoky, house-made red sauce that elevates the pasta experience. Their chicken riggies satisfy even the most discerning palates, showcasing authentic regional flavors done right.

For those seeking variety, the menu offers items like pepperoni calzones, buffalo bites, and garlic sticks that complement any main dish perfectly. The occasional hot dog garbage plate adds a unique local twist appreciated by adventurous eaters. Even the lighter sides, such as salads with house-made dressings, reflect the kitchen’s attention to detail and commitment to taste.

The intimate seating area makes Little Italy a cozy spot for friends or casual dates, while the smooth pickup service caters well to busy diners. Overall, Little Italy blends genuine Italian flavors with warm hospitality and creative dishes, leaving a memorable impression worth returning for time and again.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Service options
    • Takeout
    • Dine-in